Adulteration In Paneer: Health Risks And Challenges In The Dairy Industry

India is the world's largest milk producer and home to a dairy economy that supports millions, from
small-scale farmers and self-help groups to state cooperatives and large FMCG brands. Paneer, in
this context, isn't just food. It's an anchor of rural livelihoods, urban nutrition, and culinary identity.
Few food items carry the cultural weight and everyday versatility of paneer in India. A staple in
household kitchens, festive spreads, and five-star menus alike, paneer is more than just a dairy
product, it is a symbol of nutritional sustenance and a vital link in India's rural economic chain. But as
the country's dairy sector surges ahead, one synthetic imposter threatens to undercut it all:
analogue paneer.

The Real Paneer Story: A Nutrient-Rich Legacy

Paneer's nutritional profile is as rich as its culinary legacy. Packed with protein, calcium, phosphorus,
vitamins B and D, dietary fibre, and omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, it serves as a wholesome,
vegetarian source of energy for millions. Beyond its health merits, paneer production also drives a
significant portion of India's dairy ecosystem, from marginal milk producers to large-scale
cooperatives.

RELATED STORIES

Want To Boost Gut Health? These Factors Are More Effective Than Probiotic Supplements

While probiotic supplements can help, long-term gut health is better supported through natural and consistent practices.

Lifestyle Tips: Why Cycling Is Safer And Healthier For Everyone

Cycling isn't just fun or nostalgic. It's a practical, low-cost, and highly effective way to improve your overall well-being. Here's why you should consider pedalling more often.

In fact, approximately 4–5% of India's milk production goes into paneer manufacturing. This makes it
a critical contributor to rural livelihoods and overall dairy consumption, especially at a time when the
Indian paneer market is projected to grow from INR 570.8 billion in 2023 to a staggering INR 1,848.9
billion by 2032 (IMARC Group), at a CAGR of 13.95%.

Enter Analogue Paneer: A Cheaper Imitation with a Hidden Cost

Unlike traditional paneer made from milk and citric acid, analogue paneer is produced using
vegetable oils (often palm oil), emulsifiers, starches, milk solids, and flavouring agents. It mimics the
look and texture of paneer — but lacks its protein, calcium, and natural fats.

This substitution, often done in large-scale catering operations, processed foods, and even mid-tier
restaurants, happens without the consumer's knowledge. For cost-conscious kitchens, the appeal is
clear: analogue paneer can be 30–40% cheaper. But for public health, dairy farmers, and India's
regulatory credibility, the costs are far higher.

Health Hazards Hiding in Plain Sight

Most analogue paneer contains trans fats, linked to cardiovascular disease, and lacks essential
nutrients found in real paneer. The Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) has warned against
excessive intake of hydrogenated oils. Yet, with no mandatory display labels in food service
environments, the average consumer may have no idea they're eating a processed chemical block
instead of milk-derived paneer.

For growing children, pregnant women, and urban vegetarians who rely on paneer as a primary
protein source, the health risk is grave. Digestive disorders, allergic reactions, and long-term
nutritional deficiencies are among the known dangers.

A Threat to India's Dairy Backbone

From a rural economy perspective, analogue paneer undercuts dairy demand. Paneer manufacturing
is an essential off-take for farmers and cooperatives, sustaining incomes and encouraging continued
milk production. When manufacturers or caterers substitute milk with vegetable oil derivatives, it
creates a domino effect: lower demand for milk, reduced income for farmers, and greater instability
in an already stressed sector.

This is especially damaging given India's push toward organised dairy through schemes like Rashtriya
Gokul Mission and the White Revolution 2.0. Analogues make a mockery of those efforts.

Regulatory Pushback: A Welcome Start, But Not Enough

Various Government bodies recently mandated that analogue products must be clearly labelled.
While this is a step in the right direction, enforcement and awareness remain major challenges.
Many consumers, especially in mass catering environments, may never see the packaging, let alone
read it.

Given the scale and stakes, more decisive action is needed. A blanket ban on the sale and use of
analogue paneer in commercial kitchens, or at the very least a licensing system for its limited use,
could help protect both public health and farmer livelihoods.

Innovation Should Not Mean Imitation

This is not a call to halt innovation in food. India's paneer market is evolving, with exciting product
innovations, from low-fat to fibre-enriched and masala variants, already taking shape. But progress
should elevate quality, not replace it with deception.

Culinary tourism, food vlogging, and India's growing appetite for healthy, protein-rich vegetarian
food are all pushing the demand for paneer. Manufacturers and policymakers alike have a
responsibility to ensure that this demand is met with integrity, not convenience.

The Road Ahead

Ultimately, the paneer vs. analogue debate is a test of India's food values. Are we willing to
compromise nutrition and transparency for short-term cost savings? Or can we build a more
responsible ecosystem, where consumers are informed, farmers are protected, and real food
triumphs?

As stakeholders across the food chain, from manufacturers to chefs and policy leaders, it's time we
draw a clear line between what's real and what's not. Because in a country where dairy is more than
diet, and paneer is more than protein, preserving authenticity is not just a matter of tradition, it's a
matter of trust.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. NDTV is not responsible for the accuracy, completeness, suitability, or validity of any information on this article. All information is provided on an as-is basis. The information, facts or opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of NDTV and NDTV does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.