Q&A
If you have any query about any medical problem get an answer from an expert
  Comments: Read | Post

Can I sue the doctor who transfused HIV positive blood into a healthy person?

Friday, 11 August 2006
Answered by: Dr. Anurag Krishna
Consultant Paediatric Surgeon,
Sir Ganga Ram Hospital,
New Delhi
Google Buzz

Q. One of my relatives has been infected with HIV due to the doctor's negligence. The doctor transfused the blood of an HIV infected person. Without knowing the medical history of the donor, he allowed him to donate blood. My relative is now HIV +ve and his life is completely ruined. He has two teenaged children and all his income goes for the treatment. I want to help him. Should the doctor be punished for his negligence and victim be compensated? How can I proceed and what does the law say about such cases, especially blood transfusion?

A.  You must appreciate that all blood banks need to be registered with the local authorities and are bound by law to follow internationally accepted guidelines for HIV screening of donor blood before transfusion. Despite testing, there is a very small chance that the virus may escape detection (the window period). It appears that this is what must have happened. Although it is rather unfortunate, but this kind of infection can and does happen occasionally. I suggest that you utilise all your resources in providing help to your relative rather than go into a prolonged and fruitless litigation.

A.  You must appreciate that all blood banks need to be registered with the local authorities and are bound by law to follow internationally accepted guidelines for HIV screening of donor blood before transfusion. Despite testing, there is a very small chance that the virus may escape detection (the window period). It appears that this is what must have happened. Although it is rather unfortunate, but this kind of infection can and does happen occasionally. I suggest that you utilise all your resources in providing help to your relative rather than go into a prolonged and fruitless litigation.

Comments: Read | Post
More from this section
More »
Post comments
We request you not to tell us about your medical problems through this comment tool.
We are unable to keep track of the innumerable queries and their answers that we get everyday unless they are sent through "Ask a Question"

Name:*   E-mail:*
City:   Phone:
Comments:* 7000 characters remaining
Spam protection
Enter the code:*
Disclaimer: Material sent in this section is contributed by users. DoctorNDTV accepts no responsibility for the content or accuracy of such material and does not endorse or subscribe to the content.
----------------------- Advertisement --------------------------
 
Latest Photos
 
Search Cloud
 
Poll
Q. Is cord blood banking just a money-making gimmick?
Yes No
Post your comment | Previous poll  
 
Survey
The Superbug and India?
The Superbug and India?
Do you think it is justified to advise UK patients against coming to India for surgery based on a single report in a medical journal?
Join survey »
 
Bouquets & Brickbats
Good work...
Sent by sameer na 
More »
-------------------------------- Advertisement -----------------------------------